PUMPKIN PAINTING

WRITTEN OCTOBER 2026

01 - THE PARTY

Three couples turned six pumpkins into a pretty entertaining lineup of characters. The finished pumpkins ranged from cute to a little creepy.

Tea gathering in New York
Tea gathering in New York

HOST / JOE FULGIERI · 6 GUESTS · Holiday, do something · midtown east APARTMENT

HOST / Rad FULGIERI

24 GUESTS

BIRTHDAY

Bar blondeau AT THE WYTHE hotel, WILLIAMSBURG

02 - AESTHETICS

Joe thinks guests get more excited about an experience when they see as soon as they walk in that the host put effort into crafting it. He placed glowing ghost decorations and jack-o'-lantern lights near the entrance, then scattered more Halloween accents throughout the apartment.


He asked his friend to connect to aux and choose a Halloween playlist to play on Spotify. "Make sure it has Monster Mash, and feel free to play that song multiple times throughout the afternoon. It's a banger."


For the main activity, Joe covered the dining table with an olive-green tablecloth, arranged pumpkins at each seat, and set out acrylic paints, brushes, and little black bowls for mixing colors. Miniature silver disco pumpkins were scattered across the table because Halloween could use a little disco, too.

03 - how it came together

Joe and his wife are fans of halloween: the costumes, the parties, the dancing, all of it. But they also thinks there’s something to be said for celebrating the holiday in a more wholesome way.

So Joe invited two couples over to their apartment for a Sunday afternoon of pumpkin painting.


The other two couples had met once or twice before but hadn’t really had a chance to get to know each other. This was an excuse to change that, with six people, some paintbrushes, and a table full of pumpkins. “I always think an activity makes getting to know others easier,” says Joe.

The host planned the party to be mostly about painting but thought why not add carving as an option too…He made carving tools available for anyone who wanted to get a little more ambitious. Some guests carved out eyes or openings for lights, while others stuck to paint.

04 - THE SHOPPING LIST

WHAT EVERYTHING COST. AND WHERE IT CAME FROM.

THE PUMPKINS / $40
Six full-size pumpkins, plus three miniature white pumpkins for painting, and one gourd to add to the table decor. Joe and his wife picked up the pumpkins at Whole Foods, which turned out to be a fun little activity of its own. Not quite a trip to the pumpkin patch, but there were still plenty of oddly shaped pumpkins to inspect and comment on.

THE PAINTING SUPPLIES / $25
Joe got a larger variety of paint colors because he wanted to paint more going forward. There were smaller paint sets available on Amazon, but this is the one he ended up getting. The set came with brushes. He asked guests to bring any extra paint brushes they had too.


They used black plastic bowls they already had for mixing colors, and clear cups they already had for both holding brushes and for rinsing them in water.

THE TABLE SETUP / $90
Joe decorated the table with a few silver disco pumpkins, because what party doesn't need a little disco? A pack of 12 was $17 on Amazon.


Joe placed a miniature Halloween decoration at each seat, from cute teddy bears and ghosts to tiny pumpkin paintings. Guests even swapped them around to find one that suited their personality. It was a small, playful detail that made each place setting feel a little more personal. These were from the Asian Goods Store Daiso, and each miniature decoration cost around $2.


He has a wooden dining table, and protecting it from acrylic paint was a top priority. Luckily Joe had an existing tabecloth he wouldn't mind replacing if needed, though a disposable plastic covering would work too. For extra protection, Joe recommends placing paper towels underneath paintbrushes.

He also loved these glasses on sale at Pottery Barn. He got two 4-packs, each $27.99. Check them out here - there are some other fun designs the glasses come in.

TRADER JOE’S TRIP / $45
Joe set the expectation that there would be snacks and drinks. He got Trader Joe’s half moon cookies, parmesan pastry pups, and white truffle potato chips - all snacks he’s get again, by the way. For drinks he made one mocktail and one cocktail, both fall themed (find the recipes under 06 - STEAL IT). In addition to vodka, Aperol, dry Prosecco, and a bucket of ice, he bought these ingredients for them:


Juices - Tart cherry juice, spiced apple cider

Mixers - Ginger beer

Produce - Lemons

Garnishes - Cinnamon sticks, dried orange slices




TRADER JOE’S TRIP / $45
Joe set the expectation that there would be snacks and drinks. He got Trader Joe’s half moon cookies, parmesan pastry pups, and white truffle potato chips - all snacks he’s get again, by the way. For drinks he made one mocktail and one cocktail, both fall themed (find the recipes under 06 - STEAL IT). In addition to vodka, Aperol, dry Prosecco, and a bucket of ice, he bought these ingredients for them:


Juices - Tart cherry juice, spiced apple cider

Mixers - Ginger beer

Produce - Lemons

Garnishes - Cinnamon sticks, dried orange slices

SUGAR COOKIES / $18

The Pillsbury Halloween cookies were a must, but finding them in stock can be a hit or miss. Joe recommends checking Target; that's where he's gone for these in previous years, and you can check ahead if a location has them in stock before going. This year he got them delivered on DoorDash for $18 and saved himself an errand.

OTHER DECORATIONS / $40

Both the light-up ghosts at the entrance and jack-o'-lanterns scattered throughout the apartment were Amazon finds.

One lesson Joe keeps learning? Order from Amazon earlier. He had his eye on fuzzy Halloween-themed socks (for women, and for men) that guests could wear during the party or take home to keep cozy as the weather got colder. Unfortunately, neither arrived in time. There's always next Halloween.

05 - debrief

WHAT WORKED / The Baby Boo

The miniature white pumpkins called Baby Boos gave faster painters a second project, keeping everyone's hands busy while the others finished.

WHAT DIDN’T / Dress for a mess.

Acrylic paint can be difficult to get out of clothing. Joe would’ve reminded guests to wear clothes they don’t mind getting dirty. Or he would have had smocks ready for everyone.

ADVICE / Get inspired beforehand.

One thing Joe noticed was that everyone arrived and immediately started wondering what to paint.

He’d already decided on his SpongeBob pineapple house, so he could jump straight into making it. Everyone else spent some time scrolling through Google Images for inspiration. Joe says he always tries to brainstorm ideas before a crafting activity so he can spend more time creating and less time figuring out what to make.

06 - STEAL IT

THE COCKTAIL RECIPE / The tart cherry spritz

A festive, deep red fall cocktail without the complicated prep. Joe made a Tart Cherry Spritz inspired by Madison's Autumn Spritz Flight on TikTok.


Ingredients — per cocktail

  • 1 oz vodka

  • 1½ oz tart cherry juice

  • 1 oz Aperol

  • ½ oz fresh lemon juice

  • 3 oz dry Prosecco

  • Ice


How to make it: Add the vodka, tart cherry juice, Aperol, and lemon juice to a glass with ice. Stir, top with Prosecco, and give it a gentle final stir.


Joe combined the ingredients in a pitcher ahead of time, making it easy to pour into glasses and top with Prosecco just before serving to keep the drinks bubbly.


THE MOCKTAIL RECIPE / The apple cider ginger fizz.

For a nonalcoholic option, we made a fall-inspired mocktail with spiced apple cider, ginger beer, and a few festive garnishes.


Ingredients:

  • Trader Joe's Spiced Apple Cider

  • Ginger beer

  • Cinnamon sticks

  • Trader Joe's orange dried orange slices

  • Ice


How to make it: Fill a glass with ice, pour in the spiced apple cider, and top with ginger beer. Give it a gentle stir, then garnish with an orange slice and cinnamon stick.

HOST / JOE FULGIERI